The 1970 Club is running all week hosted by Karen at Kaggsy’s Bookish Ramblings and Simon at Stuck in a Book. The Club weeks are always great fun, so do check out the posts!
Whenever the club weeks are announced I always go straight to the TBR to see what I’ve got available. 1970 didn’t yield as many fruits as 1937 Club back in April, but it did offer four choices. Unfortunately I don’t think 1970 is my year as far as my TBR pile goes…two DNFs and a third I wish I had DNF’d rather than ploughed through. Thankfully the fourth I found to be excellent!
Daddy Was a Number Runner was the first novel by Louise Meriwether and widely acknowledged to be bona fide classic in its evocation of 1930s Harlem, through the eyes of a twelve-year-old girl, Francie Coffin. In the Foreword, James Baldwin writes:
“she has so truthfully conveyed what the world looks like from a black girl’s point of view, she has told everyone who can read or feel what it means to be a black man or woman in this country. She has achieved an assessment, in a deliberately minor key, of a major tragedy.”
From the opening lines as Francie helps her father with his titular illegal lottery, her voice is so direct and distinctive. As she runs home to try and get to school on time, we are thrust into a hot summer’s day in Harlem.
“The air outside wasn’t much better. It was a hot, stifling day, June 2, 1934. The curbs were lined with garbage cans overflowing into the gutters, and a droopy horse pulling a vegetable wagon down the avenue had just deposited a steaming pile of manure in the middle of the street.
The sudden heat had emptied the tenements. Kids too young for school played on the sidewalks while their mamas leaned out of their windows searching for a cool breeze or sat for a moment on the fire escapes.”
Francie’s family are incredibly poor, and running the numbers brings some money in. If lotteries are a tax on hope, Harlem is full of hope. It’s also full of bed bugs, rats and roaches. Poor Francie is eaten alive every night and has to go armed into her favourite pastime:
“I was sitting at the dining room table reading a library book, armed with my usual supply of weapons. Tonight I had a hammer, a screwdriver, and two hairbrushes. When I heard a noise I threw the hammer toward the kitchen and the rats scurried back into their holes. When I got down to my last piece of ammunition I would give the dining room up to the rats and go on to bed.”
Reading and schooling are seen as a way out of the ghetto. Francie’s older brother Sterling is bright and just about staying in school. Her other brother, James Junior, found school hard and, much to the worry of his loving parents, he is running with the local gang:
“He wasn’t mean enough to be an Ebony Earl nohow. How could he ever mug anybody, good-natured and nice as he was. Why, when he smiled his whole face laughed. He wasn’t like old Sterling who didn’t like anybody and whose narrow, old man’s face was full of dark, secret shadows.”
Francie’s parents are loving and kind, and how they hold onto those traits against the relentless grind of poverty is a miracle.
“[Mother] was always either soaking clothes or scrubbing them or hanging them out on the line. With all of that activity we should have been super clean but somehow we weren’t.”
“Daddy played by ear and could swing any piece after he heard it only once.”
Francie’s father is proud and doesn’t want to accept state relief or for his wife to work. But eventually he has to give in on both counts:
“They don’t give you enough money to live on so you have to bootleg some kind of work, then they deduct that from your relief check, too. I wonder how they expect you to live. Didn’t I tell you I didn’t want to mess with those people?” But for once he didn’t shout, seeming to be more tired than angry.”
The structural racism faced by Francie, her family, and everyone she knows is brilliantly evoked. Meriwether displays it through various characters, and there is an enormous tragedy looming for several families. The fallout on children is vivid, through Francie but also her peers. Her best friend Sukie is always filled with fury, which young Francie fails to see is due – at least in part – to Sukie’s father seeking release in alcohol and her sweet sister China Doll working for a violent pimp who beats her in front of onlookers.
Meriwether also articulates issues directly to the reader in her portrayals of, or references to, real life characters who Francie encounters, such as Reverend Adam Clayton Powell, Father Divine, Marcus Garvey, and the Scottsboro case.
There is so much hardship in Daddy Was a Number Runner, and outside of the home Francie has to navigate violence and sexual attention from many that grows into assaults. There’s also a horrible scene with a cat. What stops the novel being unremittingly bleak is her loving parents; her love of books; and Francie’s resilient, honest, humorous, indignant voice.
“I walked to 110th St and looked across Central Park at the lights twinkling in the skyscrapers. That was another world, too, all those lights way over there and this spooky park standing between us. But what good would those lights do me anyway?”


Oh this is a Virago I haven’t heard of. I’m glad it wasn’t unremittingly bleak (it was beginning to sound that way!) – I think the scene with a cat would put me off reading it myself, but I’m glad it’s been added to the club.
LikeLiked by 1 person
The scene with the cat is very short-lived and everyone except the perpetrator is horrified, but it still took me by surprise and I would have skipped it had I known. So I wouldn’t want to put anyone off, it’s a great novel. But I do understand total avoidance, cruelty to animals is something I really don’t want to read.
LikeLike
This is completely new to me, sounds very interesting!
LikeLiked by 1 person
It really is Cathy, very evocative!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Very good review. I’m curious–how do you find your books for these club events?
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thanks very much. I usually google what was published that year and then search through my toppling TBR piles!
LikeLike
Thanks for the warning about the cat scene— I was tempted up to that point despite the bleakness, but I’m afraid any kind of animal cruelty always puts me off. I’m glad you found something in it to lighten the darkness, though.
LikeLike
I’ve always heard about this book but never come across a copy, even when I lived in New York! Very much enjoyed your review.
Constance
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thank you, I’m glad you enjoyed it!
LikeLike
I’m sorry not all of your options for 1970 were very good, but so glad you had at least one successful read. This does sound like a very powerful book indeed, though I would certainly struggle with the cat scene… 😦
LikeLiked by 1 person
The cat scene is short-lived, I wanted to warn people but not put them off, unfortunately! It is horrible but the novel overall is so effective and powerful.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I hadn’t come across this and it sounds wonderful through the bleakness, thanks!
LikeLiked by 1 person
So glad you like the sound of it Jane!
LikeLiked by 1 person
This is one that I picked up, thinking I would read a couple of chapters, and I just burst through it all. I found her voice so engaging, the details of her life so compelling. I forgot it was on the VMC list, but perhaps that’s where I first heard of it after all.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Oh yes, I whizzed through it too! She draws you right in and it’s so compelling and readable.
LikeLike
Pingback: #1970Club: your reviews! – Stuck in a Book
This sounds excellent and though the cat scene has me wondering. If one could skip it, perhaps, I can pick this up. Some, even short ones, never leave my mind somehow and put me off otherwise good books (returning to them, that is). But a new to me author I’d definitely want to look up
LikeLiked by 1 person
It’s a short scene and can definitely be skipped. It’s a horrible moment but the novel is excellent. I hope you enjoy it if you get to it!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Will try to track down a copy 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
Slowing catching up with a few posts after a couple of weeks off for the London Film Festival, so apologies if I’ve missed various reviews…
This sounds great, and I’ve made a note, particularly as it’s completely new to me – I don’t think I’ve ever come across it before. The setting sounds very evocative, especially the passage on garbage cans overflowing into the gutters on a stifling hot day, and the droopy horse pulling a vegetable wagon. Those images give an immediate sense of place.
Sorry to hear your other 1970 reads were poor, but thank goodness this was a winner!
LikeLiked by 1 person
I’m really behind too Jacqui, still catching up!
I’m so glad you like the sound of this. It’s really evocative and with such a unique voice.
I’m usually quite lucky with what I choose, but I don’t think 1970 was my year!
LikeLike